GrowthKit

Growth Charts & Percentiles

Growth Charts for Different Ethnicities: Do They Fit?

Healthy children of every ancestry grow alike before age 5, so WHO charts fit Asian, Indian and all babies. Where national charts and parents' height come in.

By the GrowthKit Editorial TeamPublished 6 min read
Growth Charts for Different Ethnicities: Do They Fit?

Yes. From birth to age 5, the WHO growth standards work for children of every ethnicity, including Asian and Indian babies. In the WHO's six-country study, healthy, well-nourished children in Brazil, Ghana, India, Norway, Oman and the US grew remarkably alike: only about 3% of the variation in children's length came from which country they lived in, compared with 70% from differences between individual children (WHO MGRS Group, 2006). The CDC notes that the most important influences on growth potential appear to be economic, nutritional and environmental (CDC).

The picture gets more detailed for older children and adults. Some countries use their own charts after age 5, average adult heights differ between countries, and your child's own parents' heights matter a great deal. Here's how it fits together.

What the WHO six-country study found

The WHO Multicentre Growth Reference Study (MGRS) measured 8,440 children "from widely differing ethnic backgrounds and cultural settings" between 1997 and 2003 (WHO MGRS Group, 2006). The sites were Pelotas (Brazil), Accra (Ghana), Delhi (India), Oslo (Norway), Muscat (Oman) and Davis, California. Each enrolled families whose living conditions didn't hold growth back, with healthy term babies, breastfeeding and mothers who didn't smoke (CDC).

The study started from a hypothesis based on earlier research: that all young children can grow similarly, whatever their ethnic group or place of birth, if they're healthy and well fed. The data confirmed it. Average lengths of children under 2 at the six sites were virtually identical (CDC), and most differences between sites were smaller than 0.2 standard deviations (WHO MGRS Group, 2006).

So the WHO pooled the six sites into one standard, which it says "can be used to assess children everywhere, regardless of ethnicity, socio-economic status and type of feeding" (WHO MGRS Group, 2006). By April 2011, 125 countries had adopted the WHO standards; among those that hadn't, the main reason was a preference for local references (de Onis et al., 2012). For how the study worked, see our guide to the WHO Child Growth Standards.

GrowthKit for iPhone

Plot every measurement on the WHO charts.

Percentiles, growth velocity and a PDF for your pediatrician. Free to download, with a free trial.

Download on the App Store

Is there a separate growth chart for Asian or Indian babies?

Not for babies and young children. Here's how three countries handle it:

  • India: The Indian Academy of Pediatrics (IAP) recommends the WHO standards for children under 5 and its own 2015 charts for ages 5 to 18 (IAP, 2015). The IAP charts use data from 33,148 healthy children from middle- and upper-income families in 14 Indian cities. Because Indians face a higher risk of obesity-related heart and metabolic problems at a lower BMI, the IAP's BMI charts mark overweight and obesity at lines equivalent to an adult BMI of 23 and 27 (Khadilkar & Khadilkar, 2015).
  • United Kingdom: England has used the UK-WHO charts for all babies born since May 2009 (UK Department of Health, 2009). They're based on the WHO standards, and the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health says they're suitable for babies and children from all ethnic backgrounds (RCPCH).
  • United States: Pediatricians use WHO charts from birth to 2 and CDC charts from age 2. The CDC 2000 charts include US children of every race and ethnicity, because the differences in size between the major racial and ethnic groups "appear to be small and inconsistent" (CDC, 2000).

So whatever your family's ancestry, the chart your pediatrician uses for a baby or toddler is designed to fit your child.

Why US pediatricians use WHO charts under age 2

The CDC recommends the WHO standards for all US children under 2 (CDC). Its reasons include:

  • They're a standard, not just a reference. They describe how healthy children grow in good conditions, rather than how one group of children happened to grow.
  • They treat breastfeeding as the norm, in line with the recommendation that breastfeeding is the standard for infant feeding. See breastfed vs formula-fed baby growth for what that means on the chart.

From age 2, pediatricians switch to the CDC charts. Our WHO vs CDC growth chart guide explains why a percentile can shift at that visit.

When do differences between populations show up?

Mostly later in childhood and in adult height. Researchers who pooled height data on 18.6 million people born between 1896 and 1996 in 200 countries found a gap of 19–20 cm (about 8 in) between the tallest and shortest populations a century ago, and it hasn't narrowed. Heights also changed fast within countries: over that century, South Korean women became 20.2 cm taller on average and Iranian men 16.5 cm taller. The researchers note that while height is highly heritable within a population, differences between countries are believed to come mainly from non-genetic factors, such as growth before birth and nutrition and infections during childhood (NCD-RisC, 2016).

A follow-up study of 65 million school-aged children and teenagers found that by age 19, average height differed by 20 cm or more between the tallest and shortest countries. Children in some countries started school at a healthy height but fell behind their peers elsewhere as they grew, which the researchers say reflects differences in nutritional quality (NCD-RisC, 2020).

Not everyone agrees that one chart fits every measurement equally well. A 2014 systematic review of well-off children from 55 countries or ethnic groups found average heights generally within 0.5 SD of the WHO means. Head circumference varied more, though: in many groups average head size was 0.5–1 SD above the WHO mean, and the authors argued that a single international head-size standard could lead to misdiagnosis (Natale & Rajagopalan, 2014). That's one more reason pediatricians look at the trend in head growth rather than one measurement (see our baby head circumference chart).

Your child's genes: why parents' height matters

Within a family, genes matter a lot. Scientists estimate that about 80% of an individual's height is determined by inherited genetic variation (MedlinePlus). That's why a healthy child can settle on a lower or higher line than average. If your baby sits on a low line, see when a small baby needs a closer look.

Size at birth mostly reflects conditions in the womb. Over the first 18 months or so, many children then drift up or down the chart: some move up because their parents are tall, others move down because their parents are short. By 18 to 24 months, most children have reached their genetically determined percentile and then follow it until puberty (AAFP).

Here's an example girl whose parents are both on the shorter side, plotted on the WHO length/height chart:

Length/height-for-age, girls, birth to 5 years

Length/height-for-age, girls, birth to 5 years. WHO Child Growth Standards percentile curves (3rd, 15th, 50th, 85th, 97th) with 8 example measurements plotted.40506070809010011012006121824303642485460Age (months)cm3rd15th50th85th97thBirth2 y4 y
Example: a girl who drifts from the median at birth to a lower line by age 2, then follows it (WHO length/height-for-age). Curves computed from the official WHO Child Growth Standards LMS data.

She's born at the 51st percentile, drifts to the 22nd at 12 months and the 17th at 2 years, then holds that line: the 16th at 3, the 16th at 4 and the 17th at 5. Her mother is 155 cm (5 ft 1 in) and her father 170 cm (5 ft 7 in). Her mid-parental height, (155 + 170 − 13) ÷ 2, is 156 cm (5 ft 1½ in), about the 13th percentile for adult women on the CDC chart. Her steady track just above the 15th line fits her family. Learn how the formula works in how to predict your child's adult height.

Sculpted growth curve rising over a wooden chart base

Free tool

Child Height Prediction Calculator

Estimate your child's adult height from both parents' heights with the mid-parental formula.

When to talk to your pediatrician

Ancestry shouldn't be used to explain away a real change in growth. The same signs matter for every child:

  • Crossing lines. Weight or height falling across two major percentile lines on the chart your pediatrician uses.
  • Crossing after age 2. Children who cross percentiles after 24 months, or grow below the 3rd percentile, should be evaluated (AAFP).
  • Growth that doesn't fit the family. A child tracking well below where both parents' heights would put them.
  • Past hardship. Children adopted from abroad, or who've lived through food shortages, may start low and catch up; see our adopted child growth chart guide.

GrowthKit plots weight, height and head circumference on the WHO charts (weight to age 10, height to 19, head circumference to 5) and uses the CDC reference for BMI from age 2. If your child's doctor uses national charts, such as the IAP charts for Indian children aged 5 to 18, the app's percentile may differ a little from theirs. Neither is wrong; compare trends on the same chart.

Sculpted growth curve rising over a wooden chart base

Free tool

Baby Length Percentile Calculator

See your baby's length percentile on the WHO standards, which fit babies of every ancestry.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Is there a separate growth chart for Asian babies?

No. The WHO growth standards are used for babies and young children of every ancestry, including East Asian and South Asian babies. In the WHO's six-country study, which included a site in India, healthy children grew so similarly that only about 3% of the variation in length came from the country they lived in. Your child's own trend and your family's heights tell you more than ancestry does.

Which growth chart is used for Indian babies?

The Indian Academy of Pediatrics recommends the WHO growth standards for children under 5, the same standards used in many countries. For ages 5 to 18, it recommends its own 2015 IAP charts, built from more than 33,000 healthy Indian children in 14 cities. Indian families living in the US will usually see WHO charts until age 2 and CDC charts after that.

Do WHO growth charts work for all ethnicities?

For children under 5, the evidence says yes. The WHO built its standards from 8,440 children in Brazil, Ghana, India, Norway, Oman and the US, and growth was so similar across sites that the data were pooled into one standard for children everywhere. One 2014 review found head size varied more between groups than height did, so pediatricians focus on each child's trend.

Can my child be healthy on a low percentile because we're a short family?

Yes. Height is strongly inherited, and many healthy children shift down (or up) the chart in their first 18–24 months until they reach the line that fits their genes, then follow it. A steady track on a lower line that matches your family's heights is usually normal. Crossing percentile lines after age 2 should be checked, whatever your family's height.

Why are adults taller in some countries than others?

Researchers believe it's mostly nutrition and health across generations rather than genes. Average adult height differs by about 20 cm between the tallest and shortest countries, yet it can change fast: South Korean women born in 1996 were about 20 cm taller on average than those born a century earlier. Height is highly heritable within families, but differences between countries are thought to be mainly environmental.

Evidence

Sources

  1. 1Assessment of differences in linear growth among populations in the WHO Multicentre Growth Reference Study (Acta Paediatr Suppl 2006) · WHO Multicentre Growth Reference Study Group, via PubMed
  2. 2WHO Child Growth Standards based on length/height, weight and age (Acta Paediatr Suppl 2006) · WHO Multicentre Growth Reference Study Group, via PubMed
  3. 3WHO Multicentre Growth Reference Study (MGRS) · World Health Organization
  4. 4Use of World Health Organization and CDC Growth Charts for Children Aged 0–59 Months in the United States · CDC, Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report (2010)
  5. 5CDC Growth Charts: United States (Advance Data No. 314, Kuczmarski et al., 2000) · CDC, National Center for Health Statistics
  6. 6Worldwide implementation of the WHO Child Growth Standards (de Onis et al., 2012) · Public Health Nutrition, via PubMed
  7. 7Revised IAP growth charts for height, weight and body mass index for 5- to 18-year-old Indian children (2015) · Indian Academy of Pediatrics Growth Charts Committee, Indian Pediatrics, via PubMed
  8. 8Revised Indian Academy of Pediatrics 2015 growth charts for height, weight and body mass index for 5–18-year-old Indian children (Khadilkar & Khadilkar, 2015) · Indian Journal of Endocrinology and Metabolism, via PubMed
  9. 9Growth charts: information for parents and carers · Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health (UK)
  10. 10Using the new UK–World Health Organization 0–4 years growth charts · UK Department of Health and Social Care (2009)
  11. 11A century of trends in adult human height (NCD Risk Factor Collaboration, 2016) · eLife
  12. 12Height and body-mass index trajectories of school-aged children and adolescents from 1985 to 2019 in 200 countries and territories (NCD-RisC, 2020) · The Lancet, via PubMed
  13. 13Worldwide variation in human growth and the World Health Organization growth standards: a systematic review (Natale & Rajagopalan, 2014) · BMJ Open, via PubMed
  14. 14Is height determined by genetics? · MedlinePlus Genetics, National Library of Medicine
  15. 15Short and Tall Stature: A New Paradigm Emerges · American Family Physician (2008)

Medical disclaimer

This article is for general information only and is not medical advice. The GrowthKit Editorial Team are not clinicians; we summarize guidance from the WHO, CDC, AAP and published research. Always talk to your child's pediatrician about your child's health. Read how we research and fact-check in our editorial policy.

Cover photo by Jay Chen on Unsplash

Keep reading